Related Review: Pretty Boy Detective Club~ The Dark Star that Shines For You Alone Vol. 1 (Light Novel) humor mixed with deep maturity

Pretty Boy Detective Club~ The Dark Star that Shines For You Alone Vol. 1 (Bishounen Tanteidan) written by NISIOISIN/ art by Kinako/ translated by Winifred Bird

Mayumi Dojima is searching for the star she saw as a kid. She asks for help from the Pretty Boy Detective Club which consists of Manabu the Aesthete, lover of beauty; Michiru the Epicure, he of the beautiful palate; Hyota the Adonis, he of the beautiful legs; Nagahiro the Orato, he of the beautiful voice and Sosaku the Artiste, creator of beauty.

The burning question is: is it a reverse harem or not? There's a room converted into a decadent club room. The club members are beautiful, weird, and one who's filthy rich. There's a gender bender moment. The only thing missing is the twins and the broken vase. It all seems to point to Ouran High School Host Club but it's not. It's more like Ouran meets Disease Outburst Boy. But using these to describe the story doesn't give it justice.

After I'm done reading, I was confident to say that it's not a reverse harem but my confidence kept on wavering whenever I remember them calling her beautiful or the situations she got herself with the boys specifically with Hyota and Michiru that can be interpreted as something more. When I try to imagine how the anime will play out and I'm confused again. It has the reverse harem feels but it's lacking that one crucial element of romance that will officially make it as one. I'm still hoping though it may turn into one in the future? But reverse harem or not, I'm still looking forward to reading it.

And fair warning, I am not familiar with NisioIsin other works but his reputation precedes him. It felt dragging at first from the POV of the teenager with so many things running in her head but then it hooks me in with the characters and the humor and wit of the author. The novel is beautifully written and I revel in the play of words. It feels simple yet complex at the same time. It jumps from craziness then to a serious nugget of wisdom that strikes your heart then to more craziness again. Repeat. This is my first non-isekai light novel since Mia and the Forbidden Medicine Report. It's a refreshing change of pace that broke my streak of consuming isekai light novels.

The novel made me realize that I enjoy mystery. Now thinking about it I don't proactively pick mystery shows like how I would be intentional say with sci-fi or stylish shows. Nancy Drew is my first book series in elementary and I looove the Elementary series. (I sound like Manabu here.) My only problem was how they figured out what happened. There is no explanation whatsoever. But the twist in the ending got me. It's so simple and I didn't even guess it although I already felt something was off.

Mayumi Dojima in the anime

key visual from upcoming anime adaptation

No favorite character but I feel passionate about them as a group. The eccentricities in the characters even her reaction to each boy. Dojima's flair for dramatic POV and teenage angst in her head reminds me of Ruby Oliver of western fiction novel The Boyfriend List. I certainly enjoyed the character development of Dojima from gloomy as India ink girl. But in the midst of the outlandish elements in the story, I can't let go of the tiny detail of her knowing what a pressured job interview is. She's still a student who doesn't have an idea what the future of job hunting awaits right? Or maybe they prepare highschool students in Japan?

I can't wait to see the visuals of a certain villain. I love the vibrant art but I'm getting a shonen vibe or maybe a neutral vibe? I dunno what I'm talking about. Near the end, it is hinting something that makes it father from reverse harem. The twist I mentioned also has questionable consequences if it does get to romance. But I'm still excited to watch the anime which will premiere on April 10. I wonder how many volumes it will cover? Should I continue to read and review volumes 2 and 3? It may take a while though since there is no digital edition yet. The book cleverly ends with so many questions that make you look forward to the next one.

Special thanks to Patreon supporter K and Kofi supporters Hana and anon for making this purchase possible. I will forever be indebted if you consider supporting Reverse Harem Garden. Thank you! :)

Purchase titles/ related to the titles mentioned: (as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases):

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 1 https://amzn.to/3lMhj7q

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 2 https://amzn.to/3rdJH3b

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 3 https://amzn.to/3sioRkH

Pretty Boy Detective Club Manga Volume 1 https://amzn.to/3d1K5wH

Ouran High School Host Club Box Set Manga (Vol. 1-18) https://amzn.to/3vWRmq2

Mia and the Forbidden Medicine Light Novel https://amzn.to/3skClfy

The Boyfriend List Novel https://amzn.to/3faJzz8

The Secret of the Old Clock: 80th Anniversary Limited Edition (Nancy Drew Mysteries Book 1) https://amzn.to/3cY0yCc

Elementary: The Complete Series (TV) https://amzn.to/3vVq8A7

Love Reverse Harem Garden? Follow on: Youtube | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram

You can support through Kofi. Shares and whitelisting the site are also appreciated. :)

Comments

👑 18 Treasures: Favorite Reverse Harem Reads from 2020-2025 (Manga, Manhwa, Webtoons, Light Novels & More!)

Hello, Wallflowers! This is Ayreesa. I recently shared my 18 Gems : reverse harem reads from 2007–2019 that shaped me. Now it’s time for my personal favorite* reverse harem reads from 2020 to present , listed in the order I read them. Personal favorite = Some are problematic. 😅Sorry! Who knows, this might turn into one of your treasured favorites, too! Winning a copy of Mia and the Forbidden Medicine Report back in 2020 gave me the push to request review copies and start covering licensed titles + licensing news . I’d love to cover even more stories, but both time and budget keep me from reading everything on my list. To make the most of my schedule, I share quick impressions and mini-reviews on Patreon. If you’d like to help me keep exploring new titles, you can support me through Patreon or Ko-fi . E very bit means so much! This is Part 2 of 4 of Reverse Harem Garden 18th birthday series . In the Philippines, a debut ball includes dancing with...

Book Review: Spearwood Academy Volume 2

Spearwood Academy Volume 2 Episodes 6-10 by A. S. Oren Avalon gets through her first test in Spearwood Academy with flying colors...in gold scales to be exact. She's learning a lot of new things about herself, the boys, the school, the shapeshifters and that everybody is not what they appear to be. But there's still a lot of questions unanswered and more questions are being unraveled as the academy seems to have bigger plans for her. Warning! Spoilers ahead.

Reverse Harem Freshest News: The Remarried Empress Anime + Reverse Harem Titles to Check Out Before Tapas Closes

DISCLAIMERS: Some are not confirmed reverse harem unless reviewed. Some may fall under 'Kinda Reverse Harem'. See more of Bloom Index/Levels of Reverse Harem. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. The Remarried Empress is getting a TV anime adaptation in 2027. More information on ANN . Meanwhile, the K-drama adaptation premieres November 4, 2026. (Not a confirmed reverse harem. Cha Woo-min is part of the cast, but his role is still unconfirmed. Hoping he’s Kaufman!) See Webtoon Review . The rest of the mini-reviews are on Patreon. Empress Navier, whose husband shocks her one day when he returns home with his mistress and demands a divorce. Unwilling to let the Emperor ruin her life, Navier grants his request but in return, asks to marry a rival prince of the Western Kingdom, igniting a tale of political intrigue, romance, and a fight to reclaim her stolen power. The Remarried Empress, 1 (8 book series) ht...

Drama Review: The Flame's Daughter

The Flame's Daughter- 52 episodes Lie Ruge is the only daughter of the head of prestigious martial arts group, Flaming Hills. But the martial world is on the precipice of conflicts after a long period of peace and Lie Ruge is right in the middle of it. Together with first love, Zhang Feng; the enigmatic man who claims to love her, Yin Xue and ever dependable friend who secretly loves her, Yu Zihan.

🍂Fall Reverse Harem 2026 🍂 (anime, dramas, manga and more!)

Hello, wallflowers! 🌸 Here’s our Fall Reverse Harem 2026 list! This post will be continuously updated as new titles and releases are announced. Would you still like me to include ongoing manga, manhwa, light novels, and other releases? Let me know in the comments. DISCLAIMERS: Dates may change, and videos might not be available in all regions. Some are not confirmed reverse harem unless reviewed. Some may fall under 'Kinda Reverse Harem'. See more of Bloom Index/Levels of Reverse Harem. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. UPDATES : 10/20/2026 - Added Scarlet Heart Thailand and The Scandal of the Empress's Concubines anime Red River anime 2nd cour Release Date: September 29, 2026 See Manga Review . Anime Mini-reviews on Patreon. Yuri, a pretty Japanese girl, is ecstatic after passing her college entrance exam and having her first kiss with her childhood friend-turned boyfriend. However, her luck soon changes. She starts to noti...

All-Time Top Ten Reverse Harem Anime

Hello Wallflowers! I am not going to do a decade in review since I did that already a couple of years ago. but I am loooong overdue for my top 10 anime. I actually made one coincidentally a decade ago but it's a consolidated top 10 of everything from anime, manga and dramas as the titles are fewer back in 2010. I should have done it sooner but it's the nagging feeling that I should finish everything before I can post this. What if there's a hidden gem in my backlog that piled up beginning 2015 (due to pregnancy)? Fast forward to last year and major life events later, I have finished nine anime in eight months. It felt like forever. And after that, I found out I could actually start the list even without watching the backlog. LOL But the good thing is I was able to finish it and that has put off a lot of guilt feelings from me. I mean who blogs about reverse harem and never watches past the first episode??? Sadly, I don't remember most of the story of the anime...

Related Reviews: Prince of Stride, Norn 9 and Moonlight Drawn Over the Clouds

Reverse harem is not an exact science. Fans may have a different interpretation of what reverse harem is. Now, this a tale of two otomes turned animes from Winter 2015 who just didn't quite feel reverse harem at all. And I thought it was going to be the best season ever. Boy, I was wrong. Prince of Stride: Alternative- 12 episodes Nana enters Honan Academy to join the stride club.

Reverse Harem Anime Catch-Up Marathon: Nil Admirari, Yume 100, Dame x Prince, Scared Rider Xechs and Magic-Kyun

My marathon started in March of last year with two seasons of B-Project , fourth/last season Uta Prince No Sama and Phantom of Twilight . I usually blog my review before I start with watching the next anime but at the rate I'm going it will take me forever to get it all done. I decided to watch the remaining anime one after another without blogging and I finished it all by December. The last time I had this marathon was from the time I first discovered reverse harem. But unlike before, this time I feel like I was losing my mind and I'm going to quit watching reverse harem anime for good. Well almost. The only way for me to blog all these anime would be in one go...again. I'm just going to keep 'em all short. Disclaimer: As usual I have not played any of the games. Nil Admirari no Tenbin (The Scales of Nil Admirari ~The Mysterious Story of Teito~) 12 episodes Taisho Era didn't end in 15 years but continued for 25 more years. Tsugumi Kuze witnessed her...

Anime Review: Uta no Prince Sama Maji Love ~Legend Star~

Uta no Prince Sama Maji Love ~Legend Star~ (Season 4) 13 episodes The show picks up right where the last season ends off. But the winning group is unhappy with the result and another contest will be held again to decide once and for all of whose group will perform for the Triple S. While preparing for the contest, each Starish and Heavens members pairs up for a song composed by Nanami.

19th Anniversary Week Begins ~ A Reverse Harem Anniversary Roundup

I stopped making these because they took forever... but old habits die hard, because I never really stopped keeping track. So tada! Here’s another year of reverse harem and RH-like titles from the past 12 months or so. Which are your favorites? Fushigi Yugi 30th anniversary ( Source ) Angelique 30th anniversary (Source) Ouran High School Host Club 20th anniversary (Sources 1 , 2 , 3 & 4 ) Shugo Chara 20th anniversary ( Sources 1 , 2 & individual photos ) Neo Angelique 20th anniversary ( Source ) Reverse Harem Garden 19th anniversary Anniversary week is here, and a few exciting surprises are lined up! Stay tuned! And from this point on... yes, Reverse Harem Garden is older than these titles below. Uta No Prince Sama 15th anniversary (Sources 1 & 2 ) Amnesia 15th anniversary (more icons here ) Arcana Famiglia 14th anniversary ( Source ) Diabolik Lovers 14th Anniversary ( Source ) UPDATED 9/23/2026 Ikemen Sengoku 11th...

Search This Blog