Related Review: Pretty Boy Detective Club~ The Dark Star that Shines For You Alone Vol. 1 (Light Novel) humor mixed with deep maturity

Pretty Boy Detective Club~ The Dark Star that Shines For You Alone Vol. 1 (Bishounen Tanteidan) written by NISIOISIN/ art by Kinako/ translated by Winifred Bird

Mayumi Dojima is searching for the star she saw as a kid. She asks for help from the Pretty Boy Detective Club which consists of Manabu the Aesthete, lover of beauty; Michiru the Epicure, he of the beautiful palate; Hyota the Adonis, he of the beautiful legs; Nagahiro the Orato, he of the beautiful voice and Sosaku the Artiste, creator of beauty.

The burning question is: is it a reverse harem or not? There's a room converted into a decadent club room. The club members are beautiful, weird, and one who's filthy rich. There's a gender bender moment. The only thing missing is the twins and the broken vase. It all seems to point to Ouran High School Host Club but it's not. It's more like Ouran meets Disease Outburst Boy. But using these to describe the story doesn't give it justice.

After I'm done reading, I was confident to say that it's not a reverse harem but my confidence kept on wavering whenever I remember them calling her beautiful or the situations she got herself with the boys specifically with Hyota and Michiru that can be interpreted as something more. When I try to imagine how the anime will play out and I'm confused again. It has the reverse harem feels but it's lacking that one crucial element of romance that will officially make it as one. I'm still hoping though it may turn into one in the future? But reverse harem or not, I'm still looking forward to reading it.

And fair warning, I am not familiar with NisioIsin other works but his reputation precedes him. It felt dragging at first from the POV of the teenager with so many things running in her head but then it hooks me in with the characters and the humor and wit of the author. The novel is beautifully written and I revel in the play of words. It feels simple yet complex at the same time. It jumps from craziness then to a serious nugget of wisdom that strikes your heart then to more craziness again. Repeat. This is my first non-isekai light novel since Mia and the Forbidden Medicine Report. It's a refreshing change of pace that broke my streak of consuming isekai light novels.

The novel made me realize that I enjoy mystery. Now thinking about it I don't proactively pick mystery shows like how I would be intentional say with sci-fi or stylish shows. Nancy Drew is my first book series in elementary and I looove the Elementary series. (I sound like Manabu here.) My only problem was how they figured out what happened. There is no explanation whatsoever. But the twist in the ending got me. It's so simple and I didn't even guess it although I already felt something was off.

Mayumi Dojima in the anime

key visual from upcoming anime adaptation

No favorite character but I feel passionate about them as a group. The eccentricities in the characters even her reaction to each boy. Dojima's flair for dramatic POV and teenage angst in her head reminds me of Ruby Oliver of western fiction novel The Boyfriend List. I certainly enjoyed the character development of Dojima from gloomy as India ink girl. But in the midst of the outlandish elements in the story, I can't let go of the tiny detail of her knowing what a pressured job interview is. She's still a student who doesn't have an idea what the future of job hunting awaits right? Or maybe they prepare highschool students in Japan?

I can't wait to see the visuals of a certain villain. I love the vibrant art but I'm getting a shonen vibe or maybe a neutral vibe? I dunno what I'm talking about. Near the end, it is hinting something that makes it father from reverse harem. The twist I mentioned also has questionable consequences if it does get to romance. But I'm still excited to watch the anime which will premiere on April 10. I wonder how many volumes it will cover? Should I continue to read and review volumes 2 and 3? It may take a while though since there is no digital edition yet. The book cleverly ends with so many questions that make you look forward to the next one.

Special thanks to Patreon supporter K and Kofi supporters Hana and anon for making this purchase possible. I will forever be indebted if you consider supporting Reverse Harem Garden. Thank you! :)

Purchase titles/ related to the titles mentioned: (as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases):

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 1 https://amzn.to/3lMhj7q

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 2 https://amzn.to/3rdJH3b

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 3 https://amzn.to/3sioRkH

Pretty Boy Detective Club Manga Volume 1 https://amzn.to/3d1K5wH

Ouran High School Host Club Box Set Manga (Vol. 1-18) https://amzn.to/3vWRmq2

Mia and the Forbidden Medicine Light Novel https://amzn.to/3skClfy

The Boyfriend List Novel https://amzn.to/3faJzz8

The Secret of the Old Clock: 80th Anniversary Limited Edition (Nancy Drew Mysteries Book 1) https://amzn.to/3cY0yCc

Elementary: The Complete Series (TV) https://amzn.to/3vVq8A7

Love Reverse Harem Garden? Follow on: Youtube | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram

You can support through Kofi. Shares and whitelisting the site are also appreciated. :)

Comments

Reverse Harem Anime 2024 and TBA

Here are the reverse harem anime for 2024 and TBA. Some may not be full-blown reverse harem, while others are not confirmed. Please subscribe!

Manga Review: Alice in Bishounen-Land Vol. 2 (final volume)

Alice in Bishounen-Land Volume 2 by Yushi Kawata Art by Yukito With the help of a new member or two, Alice and the newly-rebranded idol group Triple S progresses in the battles. Disclaimer A review copy was provided by the publisher. Check out the first volume review . The first volume is so weird but trust me it gets weirder. But once you got used to the humor, everything seems funnier this time around. The randomness of the backstories, the non-stop comical situations, and cheesy jokes. I'm loving them all now including the minor characters. The one thing that balances it all out is Alice. She's the shining beacon of reason and her spot-on observations make it more laughable. For something crazy, it briefly touches 'beauty is indeed in the eye of the beholder'. And it's not in your face at all. It is refreshing and satisfying to get some key takeaways from both volumes when you're least expecting one. The isekai element of the story is set inside an otome

🍉 Summer Reverse Harem 2024 🍉(anime, manga, manhwa, light novels and more!)

Hello wallflowers! The season's lineup is a bit late as we do not have news of summer anime and dramas yet. For now we have kinda reverse harem, Dahlia in Bloom. I'm really hesitant in adding it in the lineup but as we don't have one yet might as well put this up. But I did see rumors of Lost You Forever Season 2 for July airing and Take Me Where the Clouds Rise (SaiMono) for Q3. I do hope it becomes true! However, I'm seeing comments that the latter drama did not get the license for adaptation huhu The Forbidden Garden edition has also been updated. Make sure to follow any of Reverse Harem Garden's socials ( Youtube | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Tiktok ) to be updated on the latest titles! And a few disclaimers: Some are not full-blown reverse harem. See Levels of Reverse Harem . Those that are not yet reviewed are considered unconfirmed reverse harem. Dates are subject to changes and videos may not be available in all countries. As an Amaz

Anime Review: Kiskis! My Boyfriends are Mint Candies!

Kiskis! My Boyfriend are Mint Candies!- 4 episodes Tang Tang meet guys who each represent a flavor of mint candies. It has a catchy, cute opening. At first there's a different feel on it which I can't pinpoint. And then I realized that they are talking in Chinese! This is my first completed Chinese animation. Well since it was way too easy to finish it. It's 5-minute ONA for 4 episodes. I think this premiered last June 4. But the first Chinese animation I watched is still currently airing (unconfirmed reverse harem), Phantom in the Twilight, which is a collaboration between Japan and China. Oh back to back Chinese reviews after The Flame's Daughter. Is China going to be booming with reverse harem now?

Freshest News: Yona of the Dawn manga enters final arc, Shugo Chara and Fushigi Yugi Byakko Senki returns, The Reason for The Twin Lady's Disguise manga on Webtoons and more!

Yona of the Dawn enters the final arc as tweeted by the mangaka. Source: KusanagiMizuho Yona reels from the shock of witnessing a loved one’s murder and having to fight for her life. With Hak’s help, she flees the palace and struggles to survive while evading her enemy’s forces. But where will this displaced princess go when all the paths before her are uncertain? The Yona of the Dawn musical adaptation has released key visuals of the main characters. It will run from July 20 to 28 in Tokyo. Source: Comic_Natalie This is the third stageplay adaptation. Source: ANN Fushigi Yugi Byakko Senki returns after 6 years and graces the cover of Flowers' July issue. There's also a colored illustration announcing the second volume's release on August 9, 2024. Source: ShojoSpain (Not a confirmed reverse harem) The final Fushigi Yûgi story in the Universe of the Four Gods begins! The year is 1923. Suzuno Osugi’s father Takao warns her to stay away from The Universe of the Four Gods,

Manga Review: I Was Reincarnated as the Villainess in an Otome Game but the Boys Love Me Anyway! Vol. 2

I Was Reincarnated as the Villainess in an Otome Game but the Boys Love Me Anyway! Vol. 2 (Akuyaku Reijou Desu ga, Kouyaku Taishou no Yousu ga Ijou Sugiru) Manga by: Ataka Light novel: by Sou Inaida Art by: Hachipsu Wen All Mystia wants is to avoid death in the otome game she is reincarnated in and to keep her family and servants safe. However, the guys seem to have bugs and are either raising or missing events on their own. Disclaimer A review copy was provided by Netgalley. Check out the first volume review . In the first volume, Mystia meets two of Kyun Kyun Love's suitors, Raid and Eric. In this sequel, we get to see how she meets Jesse, the teacher. For the fourth guy, Robert, it is more of pleasantries. The nicknames in the first volume are still not crystal clear to me. The sparkling prince. The cool tsundere. The gaudy guy. The yakuza teacher. I managed to get the first two mixed up while the other two have yet to unfold their said attributes. The competitiveness between E

Reverse Harem or Not a Reverse Harem? Part 3 of 3: Princess Maid (webcomic) 37 chapters - ongoing

Princess Maid/Maid to be a Princess (webcomic/manhua) 37 chapters - ongoing by Koowa Group & Ayu & Heibaigeer Princess Sophia is a spoiled princess of Vesperang. Then overnight everything will be taken from her and the princess becomes a maid in the neighboring kingdom, Norterang. In Norterang there are five brothers: Alex, the cold eldest prince; Luka, the second prince loyal to Alex only; Cecil, the third prince with unknown motives, and the fourth prince Darcy who is sickly. There's a fifth brother not in the picture, the youngest prince Harry. The start of the story is reminiscent of how Akatsuki no Yona started but instead of going with Hak she was taken by Su-Won. But that's how far it goes in terms of similarities and it's a different story of its own. Sophia's strength is her cleverness. It's not super battling of the wits but I enjoyed how the story banked on that . I feel for her when she's being bullied but she hangs on and proved herse

🌸 Spring Reverse Harem 2024 🌸 (anime, dramas, manga, manhwa, webtoons and light novels)

Hello wallflowers! Let me reintroduce myself, my name is Iris! Starting today, I'm going to use my real life nickname more often than my online username, "ayreesa". Iris or Ayame in Japanese is also a popular flower in Japan which goes perfectly with the garden theme of the blog, aight? Vampire Dormitory is also a spring anime but it's on the other list under Patreon. Ah, yes it's back on Patreon and as well as Thank You, Next. To access it, follow Reverse Harem Garden on your preferred socials. Facebook , Twitter , Instagram and Youtube . I've got you covered! There are a lot more anime and dramas that are not confirmed for exact airing dates. I'll update this again once we have more information. And a few disclaimers: Some are not full-blown reverse harem. See Levels of Reverse Harem . Those that are not yet reviewed are considered unconfirmed reverse harem. Dates are subject to changes and videos may not be available in all countries. As an Amaz

Manga Review: Monster and Parent Vol. 3

Monster and Parent Volume 3 manga story and art by: Ichi Sayo Saika learns what the godeaters truly are and it's not pretty. Meanwhile, Aki is starting to act strange. Disclaimer: A review copy was provided by the publisher, Jnovel. Check out the previous reviews for Vol 1 and 2 . The story turns serious and dark but in a good way as it nears its climax. E verything's on the table now including the current states of the godlings, Sow and Squeak. Okay, I'm 90% sure that Squeak is not part of the reverse harem since Saika is his mother figure. I swear manga tropes are going to be the death of me. This volume seamlessly tackled multiple flashbacks and in a short time, the characters are effectively given depth. And I just love them all. Squeak is so cute. Saika is so naive. (Not a compliment though) Mitsuri is cute when he's crushing over Izumi and scary at the same time towards Nagumo. This is Kazuomi's volume as indicated in the cover. He's always consistent

News Round Up: You Are The Apple of My Eye Korean film remake in the works, new webtoons (Truth Is, They Only Remembered Her and Who's The Baby's Father) upcoming webtoons in print (The Kiss Bet and I Love Yoo)and more!

You Are The Apple of My Eye gets a Korean remake. The movie is headlined by Jung Jin Young (of B1A4/ also in Love in Moonlight and Police University) and Dahyun (of Twice/also in Sprint). Source: Screendaily The romantic comedy drama centres on a group of friends who attend a private school and all have a crush on the same girl, Sun-ah (Dahyun). Jung will play the only member of the group who claims not have feelings for the popular pupil, but ends up falling for her. It is based on a 2011 Taiwanese film of the same name, You Are The Apple of My Eye. It was based on the novel, "The Girl We Chased Together in Those Years". Changhua, west coast of Taiwan, 1994. Sixteen-year-old Ko Ching Teng is a pupil at Chingchang High School, along with his pals “Boner”, the serious “Fattie” A Ho, the bragging “Cock Tsao” and the lascivious “Groin”. All have a crush on the brightest student in their class, goody two-shoes Shen Chia Yi, but she is only interested in her studies. When Ching T

Reverse Harem Garden

Search This Blog