Related Review: Pretty Boy Detective Club~ The Dark Star that Shines For You Alone Vol. 1 (Light Novel) humor mixed with deep maturity

Pretty Boy Detective Club~ The Dark Star that Shines For You Alone Vol. 1 (Bishounen Tanteidan) written by NISIOISIN/ art by Kinako/ translated by Winifred Bird

Mayumi Dojima is searching for the star she saw as a kid. She asks for help from the Pretty Boy Detective Club which consists of Manabu the Aesthete, lover of beauty; Michiru the Epicure, he of the beautiful palate; Hyota the Adonis, he of the beautiful legs; Nagahiro the Orato, he of the beautiful voice and Sosaku the Artiste, creator of beauty.

The burning question is: is it a reverse harem or not? There's a room converted into a decadent club room. The club members are beautiful, weird, and one who's filthy rich. There's a gender bender moment. The only thing missing is the twins and the broken vase. It all seems to point to Ouran High School Host Club but it's not. It's more like Ouran meets Disease Outburst Boy. But using these to describe the story doesn't give it justice.

After I'm done reading, I was confident to say that it's not a reverse harem but my confidence kept on wavering whenever I remember them calling her beautiful or the situations she got herself with the boys specifically with Hyota and Michiru that can be interpreted as something more. When I try to imagine how the anime will play out and I'm confused again. It has the reverse harem feels but it's lacking that one crucial element of romance that will officially make it as one. I'm still hoping though it may turn into one in the future? But reverse harem or not, I'm still looking forward to reading it.

And fair warning, I am not familiar with NisioIsin other works but his reputation precedes him. It felt dragging at first from the POV of the teenager with so many things running in her head but then it hooks me in with the characters and the humor and wit of the author. The novel is beautifully written and I revel in the play of words. It feels simple yet complex at the same time. It jumps from craziness then to a serious nugget of wisdom that strikes your heart then to more craziness again. Repeat. This is my first non-isekai light novel since Mia and the Forbidden Medicine Report. It's a refreshing change of pace that broke my streak of consuming isekai light novels.

The novel made me realize that I enjoy mystery. Now thinking about it I don't proactively pick mystery shows like how I would be intentional say with sci-fi or stylish shows. Nancy Drew is my first book series in elementary and I looove the Elementary series. (I sound like Manabu here.) My only problem was how they figured out what happened. There is no explanation whatsoever. But the twist in the ending got me. It's so simple and I didn't even guess it although I already felt something was off.

Mayumi Dojima in the anime

key visual from upcoming anime adaptation

No favorite character but I feel passionate about them as a group. The eccentricities in the characters even her reaction to each boy. Dojima's flair for dramatic POV and teenage angst in her head reminds me of Ruby Oliver of western fiction novel The Boyfriend List. I certainly enjoyed the character development of Dojima from gloomy as India ink girl. But in the midst of the outlandish elements in the story, I can't let go of the tiny detail of her knowing what a pressured job interview is. She's still a student who doesn't have an idea what the future of job hunting awaits right? Or maybe they prepare highschool students in Japan?

I can't wait to see the visuals of a certain villain. I love the vibrant art but I'm getting a shonen vibe or maybe a neutral vibe? I dunno what I'm talking about. Near the end, it is hinting something that makes it father from reverse harem. The twist I mentioned also has questionable consequences if it does get to romance. But I'm still excited to watch the anime which will premiere on April 10. I wonder how many volumes it will cover? Should I continue to read and review volumes 2 and 3? It may take a while though since there is no digital edition yet. The book cleverly ends with so many questions that make you look forward to the next one.

Special thanks to Patreon supporter K and Kofi supporters Hana and anon for making this purchase possible. I will forever be indebted if you consider supporting Reverse Harem Garden. Thank you! :)

Purchase titles/ related to the titles mentioned: (as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases):

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 1 https://amzn.to/3lMhj7q

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 2 https://amzn.to/3rdJH3b

Pretty Boy Detective Club Light Novel Volume 3 https://amzn.to/3sioRkH

Pretty Boy Detective Club Manga Volume 1 https://amzn.to/3d1K5wH

Ouran High School Host Club Box Set Manga (Vol. 1-18) https://amzn.to/3vWRmq2

Mia and the Forbidden Medicine Light Novel https://amzn.to/3skClfy

The Boyfriend List Novel https://amzn.to/3faJzz8

The Secret of the Old Clock: 80th Anniversary Limited Edition (Nancy Drew Mysteries Book 1) https://amzn.to/3cY0yCc

Elementary: The Complete Series (TV) https://amzn.to/3vVq8A7

Love Reverse Harem Garden? Follow on: Youtube | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram

You can support through Kofi. Shares and whitelisting the site are also appreciated. :)

Comments

Manga Review: Anyway, I'm Falling In Love With You Vol. 1

Anyway, I'm Falling In Love With You Vol. 1 by Haruka Mitsui Mizuho grew up with her friends in Koigama Highland. The springtime of her youth awaits her as she turns seventeen. Disclaimer: A review copy was provided through Netgalley. Her childhood friends are Shuugo, the sharp-tongued bookworm; Shin, her study buddy; Kizuki, the baby of the group from the swimming team and stylish Airu. At first, I thought it was two flowers as I'd breezed through it in one sitting. (Only 1 or two guys after her. See more on Levels of Reverse Harem ) Two of the characters became one character in my head and I missed the hint from the other guy. It was a nice surprise that wow it looks like it will be four flowers after all. (More than 2 guys after her/All the guys after her.) There's a main guy but at one point I find him too pushy so I'm looking forward to the development for the other guys. But don't get me wrong he's sweet all thought-out and especially that last arc m...

Light Novel Review: I Reincarnated as Evil Alice so the Only Thing I'm Courting is Death!

I Reincarnated as Evil Alice so the Only Thing I'm Courting is Death~( Akuyaku Alice ni Tensei Shita node, Koi mo Shigoto mo Houki Shimasu!) Written by Chii Kurusu Art by: Minato Yaguchi Translated by: Emma Schumacker While carrying out her secret executioner duties Alice bumps her head and realized she is reincarnated into her favorite otome game which won the Deadliest Game of the Year award. Together with the bad boy butler, Jack; sinful man, Leeds; the Tweedle twins and walking death flag, Earl Knightley. Disclaimer: A digital review copy of this book was provided by the publisher. She knows the ins and outs of the story but the routes are not moving forward just like it goes in the game. I felt lost at first too with the story and was wandering aimlessly with Alice. And when she decided her purpose, I was not convinced. It is fast-paced it's just that the premise was different in how the story played out. But those who are patient are rewar...

🌸 Spring Reverse Harem 2025 🌸 (anime, dramas, manga, manhwa, webtoons and light novels)

Hey there, wallflowers! 🌸 Spring is here, and if you're new to Reverse Harem Garden, I also include kinda and unconfirmed reverse harem titles. And I have actually created five different levels of reverse harem and to know more about it, I highly recommend checking out Levels of Reverse Harem after this. This list will be updated continuously, so stay tuned. Let me know if I missed anything. Happy watching and reading! And a few disclaimers: There's a separate spring list on Patreon so make sure to check it out. Follow Reverse Harem Garden's socials. ( Youtube | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Tiktok ) Titles that haven’t been reviewed yet are considered unconfirmed reverse harem. Dates may change, and videos might not be available in all regions. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases. anime and dramas S1 PV S2 PV (do not watch if you haven't seen...

Reverse Harem Anime 2024, 2025 and TBA

Here is the updated reverse harem anime list for 2024, 2025, and TBA. I will also be pausing Patreon newsletters for October and maybe November. But I would still be posting Freshest News and maybe First Impressions? We'll see. --Iris Purchase titles/ related to the titles mentioned: (a s an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases ): The Demon Prince of Momochi House: Succession, Vol. 1 manga https://amzn.to/3YjGXUL The Demon Prince of Momochi House (16 book series) manga https://amzn.to/48glqkp 7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy! (Light Novel) (7 book series) https://amzn.to/405lzVo 7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy! (6 book series manga) https://amzn.to/3ZXClFW Vampire Dormitory (12 book series) manga https://amzn.to/3ZZV18i I’ll Become a Villainess Who Goes Down in History, Vol. 1: It Seems Turning Into a High-Born Baddie M...

Manga Review: Alice in Bishounen-Land Vol. 2 (final volume)

Alice in Bishounen-Land Volume 2 by Yushi Kawata Art by Yukito With the help of a new member or two, Alice and the newly-rebranded idol group Triple S progresses in the battles. Disclaimer A review copy was provided by the publisher. Check out the first volume review . The first volume is so weird but trust me it gets weirder. But once you got used to the humor, everything seems funnier this time around. The randomness of the backstories, the non-stop comical situations, and cheesy jokes. I'm loving them all now including the minor characters. The one thing that balances it all out is Alice. She's the shining beacon of reason and her spot-on observations make it more laughable. For something crazy, it briefly touches 'beauty is indeed in the eye of the beholder'. And it's not in your face at all. It is refreshing and satisfying to get some key takeaways from both volumes when you're least expecting one. The isekai element of the story is set inside an otome ...

Anime Review: 7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy

7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy anime-12 episodes- based on a light novel Rishe Irmgard Weitzner is now on her 7th life after always being killed in one way or another by Prince Arnold Hein. But on the 7th time loop, her enemy has taken an interest in her. This is a mix of my first impression here on the blog, mini-impressions, and mini-review from Patreon. And with some new insights. 7th Time Loop is entertaining and exciting. It makes you think of the possibilities and the interconnections. Her past six lives were summarized without being long-winded but just enough to pique our curiosity. The critical timing of each action or decision will lead to different outcomes or probable "romance routes". Or so I thought. No reverse harem romance but there's a bishonen for each life. Think Amnesia. And this is by far, the fastest turn of events from a "love at first sight". I've been avoiding saying this is my...

Winter Reverse Harem 2025 (anime, dramas, manga, manhwa, webtoons and light novels)

Guess who's back? Did you miss me? I missed doing this! Sorry I've been out for too long as I try out a new project. What shows or series did I miss? Let me know in the comments. And a few disclaimers: There's a separate winter list on Patreon so make sure to check it out. Follow Reverse Harem Garden's socials. ( Youtube | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Tiktok ) Some are not full-blown reverse harem. See Levels of Reverse Harem . Those that have not yet been reviewed are considered unconfirmed reverse harem. Dates are subject to changes and videos may not be available in all countries. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases. P.S. If you would like to support my other project, please check out The 52 Weeks Planner~ Celebrating Big and Small Wins on Instagram , Tiktok and Threads . Thank you! UPDATES: 1/28/2025- Added...

Freshest News: The Lady Blessed by the Gorilla God Is Adored by the Royal Knights anime to air in April, A Tale of the Secret Saint gets an anime adaptation, Netsui Prince jdrama is now showing and more!

Hello wallflowers! Freshest News is baaack! The anime adaptation of the Gorilla no Kami Kara Kago Sareta Reijō wa Ōritsu Kishidan de Kawaigareru (The Lady Blessed by the Gorilla God Is Adored by the Royal Knights) novel will air on April 6. (Not a confirmed reverse harem.) Source: ANN via Shoujocrave The "never-before-seen gorilla romantic comedy" fantasy is set in a world where people can be blessed by various animal gods upon turning 16. It follows the coming of age of Sofia Reeler, an earl's timid daughter who happens to be blessed by the Gorilla God (who is said to be the most powerful god in combat). A Tale of the Secret Saint will receive an anime adaptation. Seven Seas has licensed the light novel and manga adaptations. Source: ANN via Shoujocrave Fia always dreamed of becoming a knight. Born into a family of knights, she's the least talented among them, but she still clutches to her hope and trains with everything she has. When the day comes for her...

Reverse Harem or Not a Reverse Harem? Part 3 of 3: Princess Maid (webcomic) 37 chapters - ongoing

Princess Maid/Maid to be a Princess (webcomic/manhua) 37 chapters - ongoing by Koowa Group & Ayu & Heibaigeer Princess Sophia is a spoiled princess of Vesperang. Then overnight everything will be taken from her and the princess becomes a maid in the neighboring kingdom, Norterang. In Norterang there are five brothers: Alex, the cold eldest prince; Luka, the second prince loyal to Alex only; Cecil, the third prince with unknown motives, and the fourth prince Darcy who is sickly. There's a fifth brother not in the picture, the youngest prince Harry. The start of the story is reminiscent of how Akatsuki no Yona started but instead of going with Hak she was taken by Su-Won. But that's how far it goes in terms of similarities and it's a different story of its own. Sophia's strength is her cleverness. It's not super battling of the wits but I enjoyed how the story banked on that . I feel for her when she's being bullied but she hangs on and pr...

Drama Review: The Flame's Daughter

The Flame's Daughter- 52 episodes Lie Ruge is the only daughter of the head of prestigious martial arts group, Flaming Hills. But the martial world is on the precipice of conflicts after a long period of peace and Lie Ruge is right in the middle of it. Together with first love, Zhang Feng; the enigmatic man who claims to love her, Yin Xue and ever dependable friend who secretly loves her, Yu Zihan.

Reverse Harem Garden

Search This Blog