Skip to main content

Drama Review: In A Class of Her Own~ latest addition to all-time top 10 reverse harem drama


In A Class of Her Own- 36 episodes

Xue Wenxi makes use of her brilliant mind by copying and writing romance stories. She will do anything to take care of her family and she's doing all this while pretending as a boy. In desperation, she agreed to stand in for scholar's examinations but ended up studying inside the all-boy Yun Shang Academy. Inside the academy, she will become part of the Yun Shang Quartet with smart and honorable Feng Chengjun,  money-savvy Yu Lexuan, and problem student Lei Zexin. This is cdrama remake of Sungkyunkwan Scandal kdrama. You can also check out First Impression of episodes 1-3 of IACOHO. 

After the third episode, I was telling myself the pacing is really slow but I don't mind. But I spoke too soon. It is unbelievably slow! I've been used to the pacing of 16-episode kdramas where each episode has so much going on. IACOHO has a simpler narrative that you can write what happened for each episode in a sentence or two. Eventually, I accepted it wholeheartedly. That's the only way to enjoy it. For a whole week or so, I lived inside a bubble where time is ticking slowly and all I breathe was IACOHO. 

Sungkyunkwan Scandal falls under two flowers (in Levels of Reverse Harem). Only two guys like her but IACOHO is bordering on three flowers. The gray area. And it's all thanks to Yu Lexuan. I don't remember the original character having hallucinations and getting flustered by the heroine.  It doesn't make sense though when they plant these lil seeds and it didn't grow into something! The only explanation is that he's like Kyoya in Ouran where he values more their friendship. 

The storyline is more or less the same and they have taken liberty with their daily lives. Most of the time, it's hard to follow the political conflict and the key players from the past. It needed more flashback for this. The only difference that is very glaring is the way they jumbled up on how they discovered her identity.  If I'm remembering it correctly, in the kdrama Yu Lexuan's character already knew.  I was looking forward to Lei Zexin's scenario in Sungkyukwan Scandal since it's one of my favorite scenes and it didn't happen. huhuhu And yeah where are his hiccups?? When they first saw the bed setup I was grinning in anticipation but I didn't really expect on how much crazy bed arrangements will ensue. 

Xue Wenxi's always frowning at the start but her character mellowed down the longer she stayed inside the academy. Life was indeed hard for her but the relationships she formed with the trio and other students have given her a happier disposition. It's just so incredulous that she's always behind in either something good or bad. She's one problematic student. In terms of looks, she's too beautiful to pass for a boy like what's new but when she appeared again dressed as a girl I was also enthralled by her like Feng Chengjun.


And for the rest of the quartet. They are all so handsome...is an understatement! Feng Chengjun is so boring in SKK but in the cdrama you are drawn to his naivete. While, Yu Lexuan started off as a minion, you will be eventually won over with his playful, boyish charms. Especially when he was sulking like an adorable kid after being paddled. If they have given him a romance angle I'm sure hell will die with second and third leads syndromes. And lastly, my Lei Zexin. I already knew that I will fall him for him so hard even without seeing much of his character yet in the first impression. And boy I did fell so hard! Even looking at his picture and seeing that smirk for a smile is just crushing my heart! In whatever universe, my heart will always ache for Yoo Ah In/Lei Zexin.

I enjoyed Sungkyunkwan Scandal but was so-so with the ending. With IACOHO, they stretched out the mundane parts and cleverly sets you up to anticipate when the heck are they going to discover her identity. It ends with making you want more because they purposely compressed the good parts. Even it has already run for 36 episodes I didn't want it to end. It felt like it was just starting. It was bittersweet feelings as I got used to binging it for a week.  According to TVTime my greatest tv binges with seven episodes are Jessica Jones, The Flame's Daughter (another reverse harem cdrama and wuxia), and now this. Looking back now,  I was satisfied with how it ended rather than having it the other way around.
 
The biggest surprise is it's now in my all-time top 10 reverse harem/flower boy dramas. My only concern then was it could only go either way. 1. I'll hate it or 2 I'll love it. But I didn't expect it to be on my top 10 and the list in my head hasn't been updated in a while.  It's far from being a perfect drama and it had some boring parts but it made me feel so giddily happy again. I haven't had these feelings in a looong time for flower boys. I miss this feeling. The last time was with Hwarang but the storyline was disappointing. I am satisfied with the remake of Sungkyunkwan. I don't think it's fair to compare the two as nothing will ever beat experiencing the story for the first time. But I love it the way I have loved most of the remakes of Meteor Garden and Hana KimiMy gender bender cup is overflowing now to last me for a while. How did you find the drama? Let me know in the comments. 

I'll be posting all-time top 10 dramas blog and video hopefully soon? Please subscribe to Reverse Harem Garden Youtube Channel. Help it reach 200 subs! Buy me a Ko-fi too and get a special shoutout on the next video. :D

Purchase titles/ related to the titles mentioned: (I may earn a small commission if anyone will buy through this)
Sungkyunkwan Scandal- Korean Drama (6 DVD, 20 Episodes) All Region with English Subtitles https://amzn.to/2RAjMTW
Ouran High School Host Club Box Set Manga (Vol. 1-18) https://amzn.to/2Rw658J
Ouran High School Host Club - Complete Series Anime [Blu-ray] https://amzn.to/32Cnz9v
Ouran High School Host Club (Japanese Drama w. English Sub) https://amzn.to/2FHEWwM
Hwarang : The Poet Warrior Youth (K-Drama w. English Sub) https://amzn.to/32DUYkd
Hana Yori Dango 1 / Boys Over Flowers 1 Japanese Drama 3DVD, Digipak Boxset, NTSC All Region https://amzn.to/3hIltJE
Boys Over Flowers  https://amzn.to/3iDaQt2
Meteor Garden ( 2018 Chinese TV Series,All Region DVD) https://amzn.to/2FBidTq
Hanazakari no Kimitachi e 2011 (Hana Kimi) / For You In Full Blossom 2011 -Japanese Drama TV Series (3 DVD set, English subtitles) https://amzn.to/3c9vYEw

Love Reverse Harem Garden? Follow on: Youtube  |  Facebook  | Twitter  | Instagram 

You can support through Kofi  or please whitelist!   




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Manga Review: Anyway, I'm Falling In Love With You Vol. 1

    Anyway, I'm Falling In Love With You Vol. 1 by Haruka Mitsui Mizuho grew up with her friends in Koigama Highland. The springtime of her youth awaits her as she turns seventeen. Disclaimer: A review copy was provided through Netgalley. Her childhood friends are Shuugo, the sharp-tongued bookworm; Shin, her study buddy; Kizuki, the baby of the group from the swimming team and stylish Airu. At first, I thought it was two flowers as I'd breezed through it in one sitting. (Only 1 or two guys after her. See more on  Levels of Reverse Harem )  Two of the characters became one character in my head and I missed the hint from the other guy. It was a nice surprise that wow it looks like it will be four flowers after all. (More than 2 guys after her/All the guys after her.) There's a main guy but at one point I find him too pushy so I'm looking forward to the development for the other guys. But don't get me wrong he's sweet all thought-out and especially that last arc m...

Light Novel Review: I Reincarnated as Evil Alice so the Only Thing I'm Courting is Death!

I Reincarnated as Evil Alice so the Only Thing I'm Courting is Death~( Akuyaku Alice ni Tensei Shita node, Koi mo Shigoto mo Houki Shimasu!)  Written by Chii Kurusu Art by: Minato Yaguchi Translated by: Emma Schumacker   While carrying out her secret executioner duties Alice bumps her head and realized she is reincarnated into her favorite otome game which won the Deadliest Game of the Year award. Together with the bad boy butler, Jack; sinful man, Leeds; the Tweedle twins and walking death flag, Earl Knightley.  Disclaimer: A digital review copy of this book was provided by the publisher. She knows the ins and outs of the story but the routes are not moving forward just like it goes in the game.   I felt lost at first too with the story and was wandering aimlessly with Alice. And when she decided her purpose, I was not convinced. It is fast-paced it's just that the premise was different in how the story played out.  But those who are patient are rewar...

Manga Review: Alice in Bishounen-Land Vol. 2 (final volume)

Alice in Bishounen-Land Volume 2 by Yushi Kawata Art by Yukito With the help of a new member or two, Alice and the newly-rebranded idol group Triple S progresses in the battles. Disclaimer A review copy was provided by the publisher. Check out the first volume review . The first volume is so weird but trust me it gets weirder. But once you got used to the humor, everything seems funnier this time around. The randomness of the backstories, the non-stop comical situations, and cheesy jokes. I'm loving them all now including the minor characters. The one thing that balances it all out is Alice. She's the shining beacon of reason and her spot-on observations make it more laughable.    For something crazy, it briefly touches 'beauty is indeed in the eye of the beholder'. And it's not in your face at all. It is refreshing and satisfying to get some key takeaways from both volumes when you're least expecting one.  The isekai element of the story is set inside an otome ...

Anime Review: 7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy

7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy anime-12 episodes- based on a light novel  Rishe Irmgard Weitzner is now on her 7th life after always being killed in one way or another by Prince Arnold Hein. But on the 7th time loop, her enemy has taken an interest in her. This is a mix of my first impression here on the blog, mini-impressions, and mini-review from Patreon. And with some new insights.  7th Time Loop is entertaining and exciting.  It makes you think of the possibilities and the interconnections.  Her past six lives were summarized without being long-winded but just enough to pique our curiosity. The critical timing of each action or decision will lead to different outcomes or probable "romance routes". Or so I thought. No reverse harem romance but there's a bishonen for each life. Think Amnesia.  And this is by far, the fastest turn of events from a "love at first sight".  I've been avoiding saying this is my...

Reverse Harem Anime 2024, 2025 and TBA

  Here is the updated reverse harem anime list for 2024, 2025, and TBA.  I will also be pausing Patreon newsletters for October and maybe November. But I would still be posting Freshest News and maybe First Impressions? We'll see.  --Iris Purchase titles/ related to the titles mentioned:   (a s an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases ): The Demon Prince of Momochi House: Succession, Vol. 1 manga  https://amzn.to/3YjGXUL The Demon Prince of Momochi House (16 book series) manga  https://amzn.to/48glqkp 7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy! (Light Novel) (7 book series)  https://amzn.to/405lzVo 7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy! (6 book series manga)  https://amzn.to/3ZXClFW  Vampire Dormitory (12 book series) manga  https://amzn.to/3ZZV18i I’ll Become a Villainess Who Goes Down in History, Vol. 1: It Seems Turning Into a High-Born Baddie M...

Anime Review: Kiskis! My Boyfriends are Mint Candies!

Kiskis! My Boyfriend are Mint Candies!- 4 episodes Tang Tang meet guys who each represent a flavor of mint candies. It has a catchy, cute opening. At first there's a different feel on it which I can't pinpoint. And then I realized that they are talking in Chinese! This is my first completed Chinese animation. Well since it was way too easy to finish it. It's 5-minute ONA for 4 episodes. I think this premiered last June 4. But the first Chinese animation I watched is still currently airing (unconfirmed reverse harem), Phantom in the Twilight, which is a collaboration between Japan and China. Oh back to back Chinese reviews after The Flame's Daughter. Is China going to be booming with reverse harem now?

Manga Review: Futei de Furachi na Ani desu ga

  Futei de Furachi na Ani desu ga (My Handsome Brothers) by Yuki Shiraishi  5 chapters (complete) Ayumu feels like a goose with her clingy and school's popular Shiratora brothers. Only 1 chapter is available so far. I wonder if the scanlators meant duckling. Anyway, the animal reference is not something new since it's from the same mangaka who wrote other two reverse harems: Ookamidomo no Shitsukekata (wolves) and Bokura no Himitsu wo Kyouyuu shiyou ka  (animal love story) . I don't remember really liking her art before but I sure do now.

Reverse Harem or Not a Reverse Harem? Part 3 of 3: Princess Maid (webcomic) 37 chapters - ongoing

Princess Maid/Maid to be a Princess (webcomic/manhua) 37 chapters - ongoing by Koowa Group & Ayu & Heibaigeer Princess Sophia is a spoiled princess of  Vesperang. Then overnight everything will be taken from her and the princess becomes a maid in the neighboring kingdom, Norterang. In Norterang there are five brothers: Alex, the cold eldest prince; Luka, the second prince loyal to Alex only; Cecil, the third prince with unknown motives, and the fourth prince Darcy who is sickly. There's a fifth brother not in the picture, the youngest prince Harry.   The start of the story is reminiscent of how Akatsuki no Yona started but instead of going with Hak she was taken by Su-Won. But that's how far it goes in terms of similarities and it's a different story of its own.  Sophia's strength is her cleverness.  It's not super battling of the wits but I enjoyed how the story banked on that . I  feel for her when she's being bullied but she hangs on and pr...

Reverse Harem Anime 2024 and TBA

  Here are the reverse harem anime for 2024 and TBA. Some may not be full-blown reverse harem, while others are not confirmed. Please subscribe! 

Manga Review: I Was Reincarnated as the Villainess in an Otome Game but the Boys Love Me Anyway! Vol. 2

I Was Reincarnated as the Villainess in an Otome Game but the Boys Love Me Anyway! Vol. 2 (Akuyaku Reijou Desu ga, Kouyaku Taishou no Yousu ga Ijou Sugiru) Manga by: Ataka Light novel: by Sou Inaida Art by: Hachipsu Wen All Mystia wants is to avoid death in the otome game she is reincarnated in and to keep her family and servants safe. However, the guys seem to have bugs and are either raising or missing events on their own. Disclaimer A review copy was provided by Netgalley. Check out the first volume review . In the first volume, Mystia meets two of Kyun Kyun Love's suitors, Raid and Eric. In this sequel, we get to see how she meets Jesse, the teacher. For the fourth guy, Robert, it is more of pleasantries. The nicknames in the first volume are still not crystal clear to me. The sparkling prince. The cool tsundere. The gaudy guy. The yakuza teacher.  I managed to get the first two mixed up while the other two have yet to unfold their said attributes. The competitiveness betw...